Scotland Against Spin
  • Home
  • About
  • News
  • Wind Energy FAQs
  • Resources
  • Galleries
    • Inverness Protest 2013
    • Perth Protest – 2013
    • SAS stand at SNP Conference
  • Accident Statistics
  • Contact Us

Letters: The future for renewables has to be large-scale offshore wind – Herald

Published by SAS Volunteer on November 22, 2018

YOUR report on the plans to replace our onshore wind turbines with even
larger structures should be of concern to everyone who values Scotland’s
natural beauty (“Scotland’s ageing wind turbines could be replaced with
super-sized structures”, The Herald, November 20). No other European
country is plastering its wild mountain and moorland areas with power
stations of industrial scale, complete with huge turbines, pylons,
substations and hill roads. With 3,200 turbines in operation and another
2,300 under construction or awaiting planning permission, it should be
obvious that Scotland is already well past saturation point for huge
turbines on land.
The future is offshore. Norway, for example has few land-based turbines –
in September I drove the length of Norway from Larvik to Tromso and recall
seeing only one wind farm, well away from people and their magnificent wild
landscapes. The Norwegians build their wind farms offshore, where the
smooth, laminar flow of wind allows the turbines to operate at maximum
efficiency, unlike their poor relations on the Scottish mainland.
Anyone in the Scottish renewables industry will confirm that offshore is
the future – today all the necessary knowledge and skills are available
and, with costs falling with every offshore turbine, there is no need for
further onshore development. The 5MW turbines in the Beatrice Field off the
Caithness coast have been put in place on time and on budget. Already a 10
MW turbine is under development for future deployment. Large-scale onshore
wind is yesterday’s technology, only pursued by commercial companies
chasing public subsidy while bribing local communities to support their
planning applications.
Now we need to identify those parts of Scotland dominated by large-scale
wind farms so that visitors can recognise those areas to avoid if they want
a hill walk without turbines. I look forward to the day when Visitscotland
produces its “no-go areas” brochure in a desperate attempt to kid the rest
of the world that Scotland still is a magnificent country to come to for
unspoilt natural beauty.
Dave Morris,
2 Bishop Terrace,
Kinnesswood, Kinross.
SOME years ago rural folk were slightly “comforted”by the assurance that
wind turbines would be in their communities for a generation only, until
the subsidies ran out. Then sites would be decommissioned and operators
would pay for the clean-up. Most were not naïve enough to believe that
would necessarily happen or the thousands of tonnes of concrete and steel
in the bases would be removed or the miles of access tracks would ever
disappear but the turbines would go. “Temporary” was the word used and some
were, no doubt, convinced industrial wind might be a necessary evil as a
stepping stone to more reliable generation. Maybe they didn’t object to
developments because they believed what the SNP administration was telling
them.
Then we started to see the words “in perpetuity” and realised that wind
turbine installations may well be there forever.
Now the watch word is “re-powering” and even bigger turbines are to be
placed on existing sites.
This is an outrageous abuse of political power. If this is to be the future
then serious demands should be met. Those that were given planning
permission prior to any mention of “in perpetuity” should remain temporary
structures. They should be decommissioned as promised.
Those that are to be re-powered, and it can only be the most recent
approvals, must have full ecological surveys done as existing turbine bases
will not be in the right place for these significantly larger machines.
They will also have greater visual impact and be potentially noisier.
They must be treated as new applications with full planning fees paid.
Why should we bankroll this industry any more than we do already? If they
fail in any area the wind farm must be decommissioned.
To do anything less confirms that we were quite simply lied to and it
should be challenged.
I would also ask if an increase in size of turbine mean more subsidies if
the original contracts have not run out? If so that is another cost that
will burden the consumer.
Lyndsey Ward,
Darach Brae,
Beauly.


Gillian Bishop

gillianbishop@ryelands.co.uk

Share this:

  • Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Telegram (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)
Categories: Other News.....

SAS Volunteer

We publish content from 3rd party sources for educational purposes. We operate as a not-for-profit and do not make any revenue from the website. If you have content published on this site that you feel infringes your copyright please contact: webmaster@scotlandagainstspin.org to have the appropriate credit provided or the offending article removed.

0 Comments

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Avatar placeholder

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search site
Planet of the Humans
Latest News
  • Herald Letters
  • SNP cannot just rely on renewables to plug energy gap warns Aberdeen Uni expert – Press and Journal
  • Which energy firms met Boris Johnson and how big are their profits – Guardian
News Archive
November 2018
M T W T F S S
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
2627282930  
« Oct   Dec »

Related Posts

Herald Letters

The truth about wind costs THOM Kirkwood (Letters, August 12) makes the statement that renewables are “far cheaper than fossil fuel and nuclear”. No doubt this assumption is based on devious claims made by the Read more…

SNP cannot just rely on renewables to plug energy gap warns Aberdeen Uni expert – Press and Journal

The Scottish Government shouldn’t rule out ramping up domestic oil and gas production, according to an Aberdeen University expert. Professor John Underhill insisted the SNP can’t just rely on renewables alone during winter when the Read more…

Which energy firms met Boris Johnson and how big are their profits – Guardian

Boris Johnson met executives from some of Britain’s biggest energy companies on Thursday to discuss the cost of living crisis. Johnson was flanked by the chancellor, Nadhim Zahawi, and the business and energy secretary, Kwasi Read more…

Featured Group

Renewable Energy Foundation
The Renewable Energy Foundation is a registered charity promoting sustainable development for the benefit of the public by means of energy conservation and the use of renewable energy.

RSS REF Blog (RSS)
  • Constraint Payments to Wind Power in 2020 and 2021
  • Offshore Wind Subsidies per MWh Generated Continue to Rise
  • Costs, Performance and Investment Returns for Wind Power Presentation
  • Public Accounts Committee Evidence on the Economics of Small-Scale wind generation in NI
  • The reality of relying upon renewable power: a personal view
About SAS
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dyUPMSJvj_E
Media Enquiries
Graham Lang (Chair)
T: 01334 828 550
E: GrahamLang@scotlandagainstspin.org
Follow Us
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
SiteLock
SiteLock
Featured Group

National Wind Watch® (NWW) is a coalition of groups and individuals working to save rural and wild places from heedless industrial wind energy development.

RSS Scottish News (RSS)
  • Ardrossan Wind Farm: Turbine fire investigation under way
  • Secretive SNP blasted for redacting key responses to wind farms consultation
  • We don’t have enough room for huge expansion in wind turbines, Scots tell SNP
  • Easter Ross community council covering Ardross set to object to bid for yet another wind farm on patch as EnergieKontor (EK) proposal comes under spotlight

  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
Developed by Design Fife