Scotland Against Spin
  • Home
  • About
  • News
  • Wind Energy FAQs
  • Resources
  • Galleries
    • Inverness Protest 2013
    • Perth Protest – 2013
    • SAS stand at SNP Conference
  • Accident Statistics
  • Contact Us

Mountaineering Scotland challenges Scottish Natural Heritage on wind farms – The National

Published by SAS Volunteer on May 19, 2019

By Kirsteen Paterson
Scottish Natural Heritage (SNH) must “stand up and protect” the land from
wind farm developers who “exploit” the planning system, an outdoors body
claims.
Mountaineering Scotland says SNH, a Scottish Government agency, should play
a stronger role in determining whether or not turbines should be built in
beauty spots.
Currently, the organisation provides advice to planners asked to rubber
stamp new developments or grant extensions to existing projects.
But Mountaineering Scotland, which represents hillwalkers, says it should
instead take up the mantle of the “guardians of natural heritage”.
The call comes as the body advocates against two proposed projects in the
hills south west of Highland village Garve.
Consent was given for developments at Lochluichart in 2008 and
Corriemoillie three years later.
However, officials allowed far fewer turbines than the renewable energy
operators sought, with ministers later expressing that the projects would
give “the appearance of one larger scheme”.
Now new blueprints have been submitted to add further devices in the same
area.
While both projects have gone for consent at the same time, neither plan
refers to the other in landscape appraisals.
Stuart Younie, chief executive officer of Mountaineering Scotland, said:
“What these further proposals do is spread development beyond the consented
proposals that were tested and constrained at the time of the initial
application and following intervention by Scottish ministers.
“It is the opinion of Mountaineering Scotland that Scottish Natural
Heritage needs to step in here as the guardians of natural heritage.
Scottish Natural Heritage have said that they provide advice.
“We need more than this from them.
“They need to share in the responsibility to protect this mountain
landscape and object to these two proposals, present the arguments that
will lead to them being rejected and if necessary, contest them in public
inquiry.”
While the new applications concern land in the same general areas as the
existing schemes, they are brought by different developers.
Fully operational since 2014, the 69 megawatt Lochluichart Wind Farm is the
largest onshore project by Eneco UK, a subsidiary of the Dutch utility
player Eneco. However, the nine-turbine Lochluichart Extension II proposal
has been drawn up by Dorset’s Infinergy.
Meanwhile, the 47MW Coiremollie wind farm is the work of EDF Energy, and
the new 17-turbine Kirkan Wind Farm plan has been put forward by Coriolis
Energy and ESB.
Announcing the move in March, the two firms said: “Whereas we had initially
been considering of project with up to 24 turbines, as a result of the
comments made to us during the consultation process we comprehensively
redesigned and scaled back the project, reducing the number of turbines and
minimising visibility from key areas.
“In granted approval, Kirkan Wind Farm would be capable of generating
enough renewable electricity to meet the average annual requirements of
around 50,000 homes.
“Using the naturally available wind resource will help to reduce our carbon
emissions, improve security of energy supply and contribute towards
achieving Scotland’s ambition to generate the equivalent of 100% of
electricity demand from renewable sources.”
Younie says that, without providing full context in their documents, the
applicants are seeking to “exploit” the planning system, adding: “The
planning system can be exploited this way by industrial developers, but we
have to remember that Scotland’s landscape is a precious resource.
“The Scottish Government has said this, and Visit Scotland banks on it.
“We need it to be protected from this type of opportunist development that
ignores previously agreed outcomes.
He added: “With the Planning Bill stalled in the Scottish Parliament, our
politicians still have the opportunity to pick up this challenge and do
more to protect our mountain landscapes.
“There is the need to move to a low carbon economy but we do not believe
that this transition need be at the expense of Scotland’s unique mountain
landscapes.”
By the time we went to print, neither Infinergy nor Coriolis responded to
The National’s request for comment.
However, a spokeswoman for SNH said: “Consultations on these proposals are
ongoing and in line with our remit as a statutory consultee, we will
carefully consider the impacts on nature and provide our advice in due course.”


Share this:

  • Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Telegram (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)
Categories: Other News.....

SAS Volunteer

We publish content from 3rd party sources for educational purposes. We operate as a not-for-profit and do not make any revenue from the website. If you have content published on this site that you feel infringes your copyright please contact: webmaster@scotlandagainstspin.org to have the appropriate credit provided or the offending article removed.

0 Comments

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Avatar placeholder

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search site
Planet of the Humans
Latest News
  • Campaigners urge Moray and Aberdeenshire Councils to think again about any more wind farms – Press and Journal
  • Section 36 Wind Farm Decisions – What are the Stats? – Brodies
  • Wind farms backed by green subsidies could be paid more to switch off – Telegraph
News Archive
May 2019
M T W T F S S
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031  
« Apr   Jun »

Related Posts

Campaigners urge Moray and Aberdeenshire Councils to think again about any more wind farms – Press and Journal

An open letter has been sent to Aberdeenshire and Moray councils expressing concern about the development of more wind farms in the Upper Deveron Valley. The document, signed by community councils, charitable bodies and business Read more…

Section 36 Wind Farm Decisions – What are the Stats? – Brodies

Energy clients are often concerned on the planning risk of wind farms and questions of “What’s the likelihood of success?” and “How long is it going to take to get consent?” will often be of Read more…

Wind farms backed by green subsidies could be paid more to switch off – Telegraph

Wind farms backed by government subsidies could be paid more to switch off than to generate power, The Telegraph has learnt. A lack of grid storage and transmission infrastructure means that the UK is regularly Read more…

Featured Group

Renewable Energy Foundation
The Renewable Energy Foundation is a registered charity promoting sustainable development for the benefit of the public by means of energy conservation and the use of renewable energy.

RSS REF Blog (RSS)
  • Why are “Unsubsidised” Wind Farms Receiving Constraint Payments?
  • Constraint Payments to Wind Power in 2020 and 2021
  • Offshore Wind Subsidies per MWh Generated Continue to Rise
  • Costs, Performance and Investment Returns for Wind Power Presentation
  • Public Accounts Committee Evidence on the Economics of Small-Scale wind generation in NI
About SAS
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dyUPMSJvj_E
Media Enquiries
Graham Lang (Chair)
T: 01334 828 550
E: GrahamLang@scotlandagainstspin.org
Follow Us
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
SiteLock
SiteLock
Featured Group

National Wind Watch® (NWW) is a coalition of groups and individuals working to save rural and wild places from heedless industrial wind energy development.

RSS Scottish News (RSS)
  • Armadale developers remove three turbines from proposal, increase size of remaining nine
  • ‘Unprecedented’ lack of trout in Burn of Lunklet following wind farm construction
  • Councillors stick to their guns and refuse to lift objection to Strath Oykel Wind Farm despite approach from Scottish Government
  • Lorna Slater flees Holyrood chamber rather than face ‘evidence’ she misled Scottish Parliament

  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
Developed by Design Fife